Remember Beanie Babies? Everyone was sure they'd make people rich, until suddenly they didn't. That same boom-and-bust pattern shows up in the whole economy, and it's not an accident.
Today on The Way the World Works, Brittany digs into one of her favorite books, Ron Paul's Liberty Defined, to explain the business cycle: why economies seem to boom, why they crash, and what's really causing it.
Starting with fun examples like NFTs and the Beanie Baby craze, Brittany shows how a "boom" built on easy money and artificially low interest rates sends false signals through the market. When reality catches up, the bust follows, as millions of families learned in the 2008 housing crisis.
The big surprise: the bust isn't the disease. It's more like a fever, the economy's way of healing. Brittany explains why government "fixes," from stimulus to FDR's New Deal, tend to drag out the pain, and why Ron Paul warned about all of this long before it happened.
What You'll Learn in This Episode
- What a business cycle is, and why "boom and bust" matters for understanding economics
- How the Beanie Baby craze and NFTs show a simple boom and bust in action
- What really happens during a boom: easy money, borrowing, and big promises
- Why the bust is when reality catches up with projects that were never sustainable
- How the Federal Reserve's artificially low interest rates helped fuel the 2008 housing crisis
- How prices act as market signals, and what happens when government distorts them
- Why Ron Paul warned about the 2008 financial crisis before it happened
- Why the boom, not the bust, is the real problem
- How Hoover and FDR's New Deal prolonged the Great Depression and grew the administrative state
- Why Keynesian economists keep missing the boom-and-bust cycle
- Why a bust is like a fever: unpleasant, but part of the recovery
- How central planning fails where Adam Smith's "invisible hand" succeeds
Timestamps
0:00 Revisiting Liberty Defined by Ron Paul
1:28 Booms and Busts, Explained Simply
2:11 NFTs and the Beanie Baby Craze
3:48 What Is a Boom?
4:03 When the Bust Arrives
5:28 A Bust Is a Symptom, Not a Disease
5:49 Low Interest Rates and the 2008 Housing Crisis
7:14 Ron Paul's Warnings and Market Signals
8:22 The Real Problem Is the Boom
9:23 How Government "Fixes" Make It Worse
9:50 FDR, Hoover, and the Great Depression
11:14 The Rise of the Administrative State
11:52 Why Keynesian Economists Miss the Cycle
12:51 The Bust Is Like a Fever
13:22 Why Central Planning Always Fails
15:10 The Bust Is the Recovery
👍 Like this video if you've ever wondered why the economy goes through good times and bad
🔔 Subscribe for more episodes on economics, history, and the ideas that shape our world
💬 Comment below: Can you think of a "craze" you've seen boom and then bust? What caused it?
Shop Resources
📘 Learn how the Federal Reserve creates booms and busts in The Tuttle Twins and the Creature from Jekyll Island
https://www.tuttletwins.com/products/the-tuttle-twins-and-the-creature-from-jekyll-island
📘 See why central planning fails and free people thrive in The Tuttle Twins and the Search for Atlas
https://www.tuttletwins.com/products/the-tuttle-twins-and-the-search-for-atlas
📚 Get Tuttle Twins books and homeschool resources: https://tuttletwins.com
#BusinessCycle #BoomAndBust #RonPaul #Economics #FederalReserve #GreatDepression #2008FinancialCrisis #Homeschool #Liberty #TuttleTwins #TheWayTheWorldWorks #Podcast
Read Transcript ▾
Hello, everybody. Welcome back to another episode of The Way the World Works. So I have been revisiting one of my favorite books, Liberty Defined by Ron Paul, who you better know by now because we talk about them a lot. And as you can tell, I really love this book and I have bookmarked too much of it. But I was reading the part on business cycles and I realized we've never really done an
episode just talking about business cycles and this boom and bust, which sounds more exciting than it might be. But it's such an important topic. So I want to talk about business cycles and I want to take some lessons from Ron Paul's book to talk about that. But once you understand this, once you understand the booms and the busts and what they mean,
it really helps make all of economics make more sense. And of course, title twins listeners or title twins readers, excuse me, you guys are far more ahead way ahead than some of us were because I had to wait for the financial crisis of 2008 to understand what a boom and bust cycle is. I didn't have books like title twins and the creature from Jekyll Island. I didn't have those books and I was little and, you know, it's only because when I, you
know, when people like me and Connor Boyack who wrote the title twins, when we were coming of age and we saw these horrible things happen and we were trying to figure out why they were happening, we came across Ron Paul and we came across this, you know, books like End the Fed and the original creature from Jekyll Island, there's a grownup book. And we found this out. And so thankfully, you know, Connor has helped take these ideas and given them to you
as his family so that you are way better off than we were having to figure it out when we were when our, you know, younger 20s seems like so long ago. But so we will talk about booms and busts now let's get into it. Have you ever seen something get popular really, really fast? And suddenly that's all anybody is talking about and people are like spending all this money on it and you're like, Oh my goodness, what is going on?
And all of a sudden it's like the thing and everyone's rushing to get some of it. And then all of a sudden it's not the thing anymore. And that market completely goes away and maybe investments were lost. NFTs are probably the thing that people might remember from a few years ago. It was like non fungible tokens. I was like, it's like, art, it was, I'm not even trying to explain it because I'm going
to do it poorly. But I think we did an episode on it forever ago. One thing I always think about is Beanie Babies and I'm dating myself there, but your parents will remember there were there were these just like little exactly as they sounded. They were like little stuffed animals, you know, with like beans as I be babies. But for some reason, someone was convinced and it started this whole craze that like they
were going to be worth like hundreds and thousands of dollars someday. So people were like buying all these Beanie Babies as investments and other people were buying them for like, like reselling them for hundreds, if not thousands of dollars because they were convinced that this was going to like make them rich someday. And the reason some of you kids are probably wondering what on earth is a Beanie baby? I've never heard of it.
You've never heard of it because that market went away and the market corrected itself. It realized, okay, Beanie Babies aren't going to be used as currency. Well, you know, it's it's how we're used to make these investments and the whole craze kind of went away. So those are kind of silly examples of what a boom and a bus cycle can look like. And I bring that up, boom a bus is going, we're going to get into more with that means, but
I bring this up to show you like something gets really popular. People are rushing to buy it. They're really excited. Everyone's like, oh, this is going to be, you know, the way of the future. And then all of a sudden it isn't anymore. And things go back to how they were.
And sometimes people lose money and things like that. So that's kind of a a simplified version. Now let's get into it more on what it means for what's happened in history and for what happens unfortunately in our economy all the time. So what is a boom? We hear, you know, the economy is booming.
We hear that every so often. So a boom is this like great times, right? Easy money, people are borrowing. People are given out money. The creditors are lending and you know, all these big projects are going to happen and all these big promises are made and things seem really hopeful.
Okay. But then comes the bust and that is one reality catches up to this boom that was never really a boom in the first place. And what does that mean? That means that people are now stuck with projects that didn't get fulfilled. So these promises are broken.
But the people that thought that these projects were going to get underway, they had never taken out a lot of loans. They had taken out money, no, they don't have the money to pay back these loans because these projects aren't happening. So what happens to them, they lose their savings or they lose lots of their money.
And so they're not able to pay back their creditors. And it's this big bust, right? It is, it is like the, the smackdown of reality. And you're realizing, wait a second, something was off here. And, you know, like most human things, when something goes bad, when now we're experiencing bad times, when everyone's struggling, what do we want to do?
We want it to pass quickly. We want to fix the problem. And who is the worst person to fix pretty much any problem we have? Government, correct. That's what they come in and say though, they come in and they say, okay, there's this bust, we need to fix it.
You know, what are we going to do? But here's the problem with this. And here's what people miss, misunderstand about the economy in general, and these booms and these busts is a bust is a natural consequence. A bust has to happen for the economy to get back to where it is. A bust itself is not a disease.
You know how when we have like a sickness, we want to prevent it or we want to, you know, take medicine and make sure that it's better really quickly. You can't really do that with a bust because it's not a disease. A bust is a symptom. A bust is a symptom of what happens when you mess with the economy and you do things that reflect an economy that isn't real.
So, for example, when the Federal Reserve lowers interest rates and this happened during the housing crisis, people suddenly thought, well, I can afford to buy a home or I can afford to take out this loan because the interest rates are so low, then I can afford to make this monthly payment. That's fine. Let's do it.
I'm going to do it. We're going to build this house. Okay, that's great. But here's the thing. Remember, I said artificially lowers the interest rate. So the rates really shouldn't have been that low, but the government
intervened and made things seem lower. So then the bust happens. Remember, reality sets in interest rates go back to where they should be. Suddenly people can't pay for their homes anymore. Suddenly people can't pay for the things they just took out loans for. So people were losing homes, then all these empty homes were sitting
there because nobody could afford it, right? So it was really bad. And we don't want people to have to suffer like that. But the bust itself was not the problem. It was the symptom of the problem that was artificially lowering those interest rates and making people think that they could afford things that they
couldn't actually afford because the resources available, they didn't exist. The government just kind of went like, well, let's pull a fast one on them and let's lower them and let's print more money and let's do all this. And so that's what happens to make people think that they can afford or that they're in a situation that, again, just isn't real. And who warned about this more than anybody else?
That is right. The great Dr. Ron Paul. He was always warning about, you know, booms and busts and how we need to be really careful and understanding that when the government intervenes with the market, it distorts signals. I've already talked about those little like little like messages, little,
like think I called them like little floating text messages that we can't see. But there's these little signals that send to different people in the market. You know, this is how much I should price this for because people will pay this much for it. It's this information, this data. So when that's distorted, when the government gets involved and like
re-unsend those messages or sends a fake one out and tells you something that isn't true, what happens? So the market gets distorted and then all of a sudden there is this crash because the market has to correct itself. And Ron Paul was warning about this. Ron Paul was warning about these kind of things that were going to lead to the 2008
financial crisis before they even happened. And when it did happen and a lot of us were watching people whose businesses and people suffer, you know, Ron Paul would be on a debate stage or giving a speech. And he would be explaining this boom and bust cycle. And it really made you think like, Oh, I get it. This is why this is happening.
The government messed with the market and tried to tell us that these were the resources available, but that wasn't real. That was just this, this mirage of what was really there. So where people think the problem is this bust in this cycle. It's actually the boom. The real problem is when everybody thinks everything is great because
interest rates are low and the government's printing more money. And oh, we have all this, this money, but that's the problem. The bust is what happens because of that problem. The bust isn't the problem. But as if government didn't make things worse. So not only are they starting the booms by, you know, again, artificially
lowering interest rates, the creature from Jekyll Island. Great book to refresh after this episode. So they're doing that. But then the market corrects. That's the bust where the market goes, whoa, whoa, whoa. These are not the real signals.
This is how it should be. Let's let things go. So it needs to correct markets need to have those corrections. But people don't like to go through hard times. Understandably, people don't want to struggle. They want to fix it.
They go to government and they say, please, please fix us. And this is how we get even bigger crises that aren't just recessions. They're depressions, like the Great Depression. So one of the things governments love doing is, again, they like stimulating the economy. Let's give stimulus checks.
Let's do all this. Let's encourage buying. And they do that by printing more money. And all of a sudden, though, it doesn't fix anything. Things are prolonged. And and this is what happened with the Great Depression, which is so funny
because people love to look at FDR as this great president. And in fact, people will always try to say he got us out of the Great Depression for getting that FDR actually made the Depression longer. So Hoover gets a lot of blame because that's who it started under. But Hoover and FDR were very similar. They both wanted these higher wages.
They both wanted this economy that didn't actually exist. So when Hoover is added and FDR comes in, he's going to fix the Great Depression. But what does he do? He prolongs it because he grows government. This new deal is what they called it expanded government.
It was doing so many ridiculous things. It was like paying farmers not to farm. That sounds crazy. We're going to get into that in a different episode. I don't have time on this one today. But there were all these bad policies put into place.
These FDR thought that he and his government could fix the Great Depression by adding more layers of government intervention, which how do these booms get started in the first place? We talked about this, the market distorting these signals. So it's it's like they create a problem, then try to create a solution and then wait, it's going to take even longer to get out of this.
So the Great Depression or the Great Depression and the new deal that was allegedly the greatest thing that America ever saw and it helped fix everything. I said that in scare quotes for those of you just listening to the audio and not seeing the video. It wasn't this great deal. It expanded government actually guys, it expanded the government in ways that
we are still dealing with today. The growth of what we call the administrative state. That's all those alphabet agencies. Like you think of like TSA, EPA, all these things, they were in power. They were emboldened during FDR trying to fix the Great Depression. So every time the government tried to do something, they were actually
delaying the recovery, right? Nobody wanted to struggle. Nobody wanted to go through the hardship of having to let things run their course, trying to have things get better slowly. But every time the government intervened, the recovery took a little bit longer and a little bit longer.
And what I think is so just that makes me so distraught and that I think makes probably people like Ron Paul who've been screaming about this forever. So distraught is that even now, you know, people like us who read the title twins, we understand what's going on. We understand the boom and bust cycles. But when you go to these like Keynesian economists, Keynes was this.
He's like a villain. Actually, we'll do a whole episode on Keynes one day. But he was the this guy that believed that we needed government intervention that this wasn't bad, but they refused to even acknowledge these boom and bust cycles. So when you don't even acknowledge the problem, you're just going to repeat it again and again and again, because they don't understand that these booms,
I am saying that in scare quotes, is not a boom. The boom is the the disease, the sickness. The bust is that is like a actually, here's a good example. You know how when you get sick and you get a fever, you think the fever is awful. Nobody likes having a fever, but a fever is actually good. A fever, obviously to have a fever can be a problem.
But when you get a fever, that's your immune system. That's your body saying we got a recover. We're going to recover. So I'm, you know, stepping up the immune system and calling reinforces. It's going to be unpleasant. You're going to be really, really hot for a little bit.
But let's get your immune system going. Okay. That that fever is kind of like these, these bus. We need them. The bus have to happen to to kick into gear our immune system, the economic immune system to to help us recover quickly and not prolong it with government intervention.
And, you know, all this points back to a bigger problem. Part of the reason that a lot of what we talk about here, a lot of what's in the Tuttle Twin books is about making sure that governments don't central plan, you know, trying to explain to people why central planning is so bad. And it's, it's not hard to see when you look at the boom and bust cycles and what they've did historically because you can see that this central planning of, you
know, when government does central plan, they do things that hurt us. They do things that intervene or that aren't even a real reflection of the real economy, that aren't a reflection of the real resources available. There's prices, there's market signals. There's all these things that tell us what to do and tell the market what to do. This is invisible hand.
Adam Smith talked about without the government needing to be involved, right? It's, it's a, the, the economy is a, is an organic human thing. We all work together to make it work. The government steps in and tries to plan it. It always goes badly. I cannot emphasize this enough.
It always goes badly. So that is what we mean when we talk about boom and bust cycles, you know, thanks to people like Ron Paul, a lot of people like me, again, like Connor, we really got into this stuff. That's why I'm here today because we thought, Oh, it's actually not that hard. I wish economists that the mainstream economist, the Keynesian economist,
I wish they would understand this, right? Because it's pretty easy to understand if the government lowers the cost of things and then people think that it's low because there's tons out there, right? Oh, if it's low, that means there must be tons of resources for us to get. But then that's not real. And then the market corrects and then all these people don't have these resources.
It's like pulling the rug out from under somebody. So boom and bust cycles. I know I've said it a million times. It's kind of fun to say it boom and bust cycles. But these are something we need to understand. We also need to understand that the bust, again, one more time to say it.
The bust isn't the sickness. The bust isn't the disease. The bust is the recovery. It's that fever that we have to go through. It's unpleasant, but we need it. I will leave it there as always.
Don't forget to like and subscribe to the podcast. And until next time, I will talk to you later.