735. There Are No Solutions, Only Trade-Offs

Click below to Subscribe
Tuttle Twins podcast: 735. There Are No Solutions, Only Trade-Offs
735. There Are No Solutions, Only Trade-Offs
15
1x
15

Healthcare too expensive? Make it free. Wages too low? Raise them. So why don't these "easy fixes" ever work out the way politicians promise?

Today on The Way the World Works, Brittany unpacks the economist quote she repeats more than any other. Thomas Sowell said it best: "There are no solutions, only trade-offs." It sounds simple, but it changes the way you look at every policy debate and every decision you make.

Using everyday examples like spending your allowance or staying up late, Brittany explains what a trade-off really is. Then she walks through two big policy examples, the minimum wage and rent control in New York City, to show how a "solution" for one group often just shifts the problem onto someone else.

She shares four simple questions you can ask about any new policy, and explains why freedom doesn't promise perfect outcomes, but does let each person choose their own trade-offs.

What You'll Learn in This Episode

  • What Thomas Sowell meant by "There are no solutions, only trade-offs"
  • Why "let's just make it free" ideas always come with hidden costs
  • What a trade-off is, explained with allowance and bedtime examples
  • How Bastiat's broken window fallacy reveals the costs we don't see
  • How raising the minimum wage can lead to layoffs, higher prices, and closed small businesses
  • Why rent control in New York led to fewer homes, not cheaper housing
  • How many policies simply shift a problem from one group to another
  • Four questions to ask about any policy: What improves? What gets worse? Who benefits? Who pays?
  • What opportunity cost means for your own time and choices
  • Why freedom lets each person decide which trade-offs are worth it
  • A family homework challenge to name the trade-off in your next decision

Timestamps

0:00 Thomas Sowell's Favorite Quote
0:33 Why "Just Fix It" Sounds So Easy
1:33 What Is a Trade-Off?
2:02 Staying Up Late: An Everyday Example
2:32 Bastiat and What Is Not Seen
3:27 The Minimum Wage Trade-Off
4:25 Rent Control in New York
5:56 Shifting the Problem to Someone Else
6:24 Four Questions to Ask About Any Policy
8:33 Trade-Offs in Your Own Life
9:04 Opportunity Cost
9:32 Freedom Doesn't Promise Perfect Outcomes
11:29 Your Homework: Name the Trade-Off

👍 Like this video if you've ever wondered why "easy fixes" never seem to work
🔔 Subscribe for more episodes on economics, history, and the ideas that shape our world
💬 Comment below: What's a decision you made this week, and what trade-off did you accept to make it?

Shop Resources

📘 Learn how money, markets, and prices really work in The Tuttle Twins and the Creature from Jekyll Island
https://www.tuttletwins.com/products/the-tuttle-twins-and-the-creature-from-jekyll-island

📘 Discover what happens when the people who make the world work disappear in The Tuttle Twins and the Search for Atlas
https://www.tuttletwins.com/products/the-tuttle-twins-and-the-search-for-atlas

📚 Get Tuttle Twins books and homeschool resources: https://tuttletwins.com

#ThomasSowell #TradeOffs #Economics #MinimumWage #RentControl #OpportunityCost #UnintendedConsequences #Homeschool #Liberty #TuttleTwins #TheWayTheWorldWorks #Podcast

Read Transcript

Hello everybody. Welcome back to another episode of The Way the World Works. Today, I want to talk about Thomas Sol, who we have talked about before on the show, but I want to talk about specifically one of his quotes that I've quoted a lot on the show in the past. And honestly, I quoted a lot in life. I think it might be the biggest economist quote that I say over and over again, because quite honestly, I find it applicable in almost every situation I am in. So let's get into it. So the quote is, there are no solutions

only trade-offs. What in the world does that mean? Well, we're going to get into it right now. If you ever pay attention to what's going on in Congress or what's going on in the world in politics, you'll hear people always say, no, why don't we just fix the problem? There's all these problems. Let's just fix it. You know, health care is too expensive. Let's just give everybody free health care. College tuition too high. Let's just give everybody free college, right? People are making enough. Let's just raise the minimum wage. Like, duh, right? You think, oh, that's great. That's

an easy solution. Why can't we do that? Well, while there are a lot of politicians, like I think of Bernie Sanders, people like that, who would love to just make everything free. And that would be the solution. Thomas Sol grounds us and reminds us that there are no such thing as solutions. They just don't exist. There's only trade-offs. And I know that just sounds repetitive. It's just what I just said. So let's get into what I mean based on what I just said with giving you tangible solutions and problems. So let's start at the beginning. What on earth is a trade-off? Well, we hear the word

trade in it so we can kind of guess there's some exchange going on. And there is what it is, it's you get a little, but you give a little to get that, right? So you're trading. You're making that trade. So what does that look like in practice? So you got allowance, okay? You can spend that allowance today on something you want today, but you're not going to have money to spend in a week because you would have already spent that. So that's one example. Let's say there's a show you really want to watch or there's a friend over or something and you want to stay up a little later.

Okay, you can stay up a little later. That's the solution to I want to stay up later solution. I get to stay up later. But what is the trade-off? The trade-off is you're probably going to be tired of the morning because you still have things you have to do. So you have to get up. See, so you're getting the thing, you get to stay up later, but you're giving up being tired the next day. So there are these costs to everything. There are these trade-offs, as Thomas Sol would call them. So to every yes, there's also a no, right? There's also something else. There is no perfect solution

to everything, even though people would like to believe that there is. And that goes both ways, but let's talk about it first in terms of these policy problems or people think, you know, why don't we just raise them in on wage? Well, remember, Bostia talked about what is not seen that sometimes we have the broken window fallacy and there are things that you break a window, you think, oh, well, that's great, because now the window maker, he's going to get money. But you forget that the store owner with the broken window, he now has to pay for the window, repair man.

I don't know if that's a thing, but you know what I'm saying? The glass does the glass. But now because he had to pay for that, he doesn't have money to buy new things for his store that more people want to buy, right? So there are these trade-offs and sometimes we don't always see what they are. So when politicians who are very well-intentioned, people don't want to bankrupt the economy, always, there are some people that truly think that what they want to do is correct. People with very big hearts who don't want to see people struggling financially. And so

why don't we just raise them in on wage? It's a great idea. But what do we know? What do we know about that? What is the trade-off of that? So let's say we say, yes, Congress votes, we raise the minimum wage. Well now, smaller businesses, they can't afford to raise the minimum wage, but now they're being told they have to. So what happens? They've got to lay workers off, or maybe they just have to make the cost higher to consumers. So whatever they're selling, they have to now sell for more because they have to be able to make up for that money so that they

can comply with the legal minimum age. Or worst case scenario, now this guy, this little business owner who you love, he's your favorite. I don't know, maybe it's like a coffee shop or a book shop or something. He now can't afford to run his business. And so what has to happen? He has to shut down. That's the trade-off. So while the policy makers, the lawmakers, the politicians are saying, well, why don't we just raise the minimum wage? That'll help everybody get ahead financially. But now you've put all these small businesses out of business, and now people are still

struggling financially. So there is no solution. That solution of raising the minimum wage, it wasn't a real solution. There was a trade-off. There's only trade-offs. And that's what Thomas Sol's quote is saying. So another example, and we see this in New York is rent control. So a long time ago, there was this great idea from policymakers saying, let's make it illegal for landlords to raise the rent on their own property. They've got to keep this rent the same, or they're only allowed to raise a teeny bit. They have to stay within these government bounds.

That's going to be great. Everyone's going to be able to afford housing. What do you think happened? Well, let's talk about it. So the problem was housing is too expensive. The government's solution was let's make rent a certain amount. It can't go above that. Okay. Well, just like the store owners who now can't afford to do certain things with their business, now landlords aren't incentivized to really take care of their properties because they don't even have the money to take care of their properties because they're not getting enough from the rent.

And now because there's less money going around, fewer new apartment buildings, fewer new houses are going up because people simply can't afford to do that because they know that if they do, they're not in control of the rent people are going to pay them. The government is mandating what somebody gets to pay them. And because of this, what has happened in places with strict rent control like New York, there's not enough housing for people. There isn't enough housing. So that was the trade off, right? Solution, lower rents, we're going to make sure that rent is controlled.

Oh, but wait, the trade off is now we don't have enough places for anyone to live. So the problem was that we were worried people weren't going to be able to afford housing. So we made rent cheap and now people can't afford housing, but maybe it's a different group of people than we thought before. See, so it's just like trading off literally. It's pushing the problem to someone else or somewhere else, but it is still causing another problem. There's a trade off. So when you see politicians proposing something and you see it a lot from,

again, Bernie Sanders, AOC, you're probably going to see a lot of things coming out of New York, because I'm Donnie, the new, the new mayor of New York City is just like AOC in Bernie Sanders, especially in things like rent control. I think you're going to see a lot of this stuff coming out. So I want to read off some questions that I crafted for you guys to ask whenever you hear of a policy and you want to know, like, all right, what is the solution or what are the trade off? So first ask, what does this policy improve or what is it saying it's going to improve?

Okay, what does it make worse? So what does it improve? What does it make worse? Who benefits? And then who pays? It's always us. It's always us to pay, but it's not just tax dollars, it's other things. So again, let's use, let's use another example here, especially when it comes to policy. So let's go back to the minimum wage analogy, right? So what is the solution? Again, the solution to the problem is people aren't making enough. Let's raise the wages while people make enough. That's great. Okay, what gets worse from that? What gets worse from that

is business owners now can't pay their people. They may have to go out of business or sometimes these low, like these lower entry jobs now because the wage is so high, they just get rid of those jobs. So now unskilled workers can't learn a new skill and rise up. So there's a whole other thing, right? So who benefits? Maybe one group of people does. The people who are now have a higher wage, they might be benefiting, right? But who pays for it? A different group. You're just shifting the problem to a new group and sometimes, actually, all the time. So even though there's that one group that's

now making higher wages, if everybody now is having to raise the costs or businesses are going out of business, things like that, then prices are going to raise actually for everybody across the board eventually. So really, everybody loses. But in the immediate future, we're saying that it's just shifting the problem to somebody else. That is the trade off. But it's not only policies. This is the number I said I use this quote in my life all the time because it's not just a policy world thing. It's something that we can take into our lives. Every time you make a decision,

you're making a decision to do one thing over another thing, right? So let's say that I decide that I really want to learn a new skill or that I really want to make more money so I take on all these smaller jobs in addition to the jobs I already have. Well, that's great because I am getting more money, right? So the solution is maybe I want more money. Here's I'm going to take a couple jobs. I'm going to make more money. That's great. But wait, what's what's happening here? Now I'm tired. Now I have no time for anything. Now my free time is completely taken up. And so I've given

up something. This is opportunity cost, right? I've given up one thing for another thing. And I have to make sure that that is the correct trade off I want. I need to make sure that that's something I'm comfortable with. And maybe it's not right. It has to go back to that staying up late, staying up late can be so fun every now and then. But if you still have to get up at six in the morning, maybe it's not so fun because now I have to pay for it tomorrow. I'm giving something up. So it's not just in policy world, it's not just an economic principle. It's also just something

we can take in life, everything in life. There are no solutions. There are only trade offs. And we have to remember that because I think that's so important. And it sets us up for a very realistic view of the world and what each decision is. So I want to make one more example. And that's on the flip side of things, which is, you know, for those of us who really love individual liberty, really love free markets, I think there'll be a lot of critics that maybe come to us and say, well, I don't know why you think your, you know, ideology or your thoughts are

so great when there's somebody who's always going to be a loser, right? In the free market, not everybody can be winners. There's going to be winners and losers. So, you know, you're at your solutions to things aren't real solutions. You're not going to fix all the problems, you know, maybe you're so anti war, but now there's going to be a country who struggles because you don't want us to get involved in this. And there's always going to be people saying, you know, there's still going to be bad outcomes, even if you get this perfect, you know, free market

libertarian society. But the answer to that would be that freedom, this ability, you know, to live in a free market where we get to choose for ourselves or we get to be individuals, freedom does not guarantee perfect outcomes, okay? But it lets each person decide what those tradeoffs are for themselves. And in my opinion, the closest we can get to freedom and to living living our best lives, as people say, is being able to make those choices for ourselves. But so many policymakers, so many people want to control outcome. And they think if we have this

good outcome, like the higher wages for everybody, that everything is going to be good. But as we know, first of all, that doesn't work because there are solutions later it does, there's that code again. But also, it doesn't allow for the most freedom, you're still trying to force something. And as we all know, when government uses force, things just don't work out to the way they think they're going to. So Thomas Sol's quote is just so important. And again, one of those things you can take to every scenario in your life. And so my homework assignment to you guys,

I want you next time you have to make a decision, and this could be any decision, I want you to repeat the quote, you should know it by now, because I've said it like 50,000 times, there are no solutions, only trade offs. And I want you to think about what you're giving up and what you're gaining in every decision. And again, this could be something small, it could be what breakfast am I going to have this morning? Okay, well, if I have eggs, I have this, and maybe it's a bigger decision, maybe it's I want to skip soccer practice today. And then I'll get the rest

I need some really tired today. But I won't be prepared for that big game on Saturday. So I want you to think about that I want you to maybe even write down or discuss as a family, what were you giving up and what were you gaining? And I want you to really put Thomas Sol's words into practice, so I will leave it there. As always, don't forget to like and subscribe to the podcast. And until next time, I will talk to you later.