What do public bathrooms and socialism have in common?

What do public bathrooms and socialism have in common?

Well, they're filthy, there's never enough toilet paper, something is always broken and the things that aren’t rarely seem to work the way they're supposed to.

(Raise your hand if you’ve been stuck frantically waving your soapy fingers under a faucet that has decided you've had enough water.)

Oh, and there's always a line.

But there’s an even better comparison, and James here makes it beautifully:

Now, I know that a dirty public restroom isn't exactly scientific proof that socialism doesn't work, but lucky for us, there’s a well-documented, long and terrible history of real socialism actually not working.

The rise in the popularity of socialism is an indicator that too many people have either forgotten or are unaware of one very important truth: Human beings respond to incentives.

When you own something, you've generally got a pretty good reason to take care of it. When you worked to acquire it, you're probably even more inclined to protect it. And when you're responsible for the cost of your decisions, you're more likely to think about the consequences.

But when everyone gets to use something, nobody feels particularly responsible for maintaining it, and someone else gets stuck with the bill, things can get messy. Sometimes literally.

Economists have a name for a related problem: the tragedy of the commons. It's what can happen when people share a resource but have no clear individual responsibility for preserving it. Everyone has an incentive to use it, while the incentive to maintain it is considerably weaker. Some people argue that this is a reason that the government should have more control over everything, but a more accurate argument is that government is the ultimate cause of the tragedy of the commons.

Lots of smart people have taken notice of the rising popularity of socialism, communism, and other forms of collectivism.

Author and economist Daniel Lacalle recently wrote an interesting piece about the growing popularity of socialism among Americans who are frustrated with the economy. His argument is that we're increasingly blaming capitalism for problems that government intervention has actually caused.

I think he’s right.

Consider what young Americans are experiencing right now. Housing is unaffordable, wages haven't kept pace with many of the expenses families face, and the prospect of building the kind of life their parents enjoyed seems increasingly out of reach.

It's understandable that they'd be frustrated. But they're looking at an economy shaped by decades of government spending, monetary intervention, subsidies, regulations, and political favoritism, and concluding that the free market is the problem.

Take housing, for example. In many American cities, local governments have spent decades restricting what can be built, where it can be built, and how much of it can be built. Zoning restrictions, permitting requirements, and other barriers make it harder and more expensive to increase the housing supply, particularly in places where people actually want to live.

When housing becomes unaffordable, what's one of the first solutions politicians propose? More government programs, more subsidies, and more intervention in the very market they've already helped distort.

There's a certain irony in making something more expensive through regulation and then offering taxpayers a subsidy to help them afford it.

Consider what happens when large corporations make terrible financial decisions and the government steps in to rescue them. The executives get to enjoy the profits when things go well, but when things go badly, taxpayers are expected to absorb the losses.

That's not capitalism functioning as it should. That's a system in which political connections protect people from the consequences of their decisions.

And it creates exactly the wrong incentives.

Why should a business carefully evaluate risk if it expects the government to rescue it? Why should politicians worry about the long-term consequences of spending money they don't have when the bill will come due long after they're out of office?

The same principle that makes someone less inclined to clean up a bathroom they don't feel responsible for becomes considerably more consequential when we're talking about banks, corporations, and politicians making decisions with other people's money.

Meanwhile, ordinary Americans are left paying for the consequences, and they're increasingly told that the solution is to give the government even more control.

I don't think most people who are attracted to socialism are hoping for shortages, dependency, or an economy run by politically connected bureaucrats. They definitely don’t think they’ll end up eating zoo animals. They just want affordable homes, decent wages, opportunities for their children, and some confidence that working hard will allow them to build a better life.

Those are perfectly reasonable things to want!

But good intentions don't change how incentives work. We still have to ask who makes the decisions, who bears the costs, who gets the rewards, and what happens when the people making those decisions don't have to live with the consequences.

Those are some of the ideas we explore in The Tuttle Twins and the Messed Up Market. In it, Ethan and Emily learn what happens when governments interfere with markets, protect people from the consequences of bad decisions, and distort the incentives that help an economy function.

It’s just one of our many resources that help kids learn true economic and civic principles.

I wish more young people understood these ideas before reaching adulthood and encountering politicians promising to fix every economic problem with another government program.

I’m grateful to parents like you who are doing all they can to teach their kids the truth.

Those kids are really our only chance at a free and prosperous future.

— Connor

FREE DOWNLOAD

Protect Your Kids Today

There are many subtle ways that socialist ideas are being introduced, taught, and reinforced directly to your children. Our e-book walks through several examples to help raise your attention to this agenda so you can help your children avoid being indoctrinated to support the state.

CHILDREN'S BOOKS (AGE 5 - 11)

Our American History Books + Curriculum

FICTION BOOKS (AGE 12+)

NON-FICTION BOOKS (AGE 12+)

BOOKS FOR TODDLERS

SumthinWhittee

Hopefully Santa gives these out this year. Best gift to help counter the elementary school propaganda. #tuttletwins

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

LadyKayRising

When ur bedtime story teaches ur girl about the federal reserve & what a crock of crap it is. Vocab words: Medium of exchange & fiat currency. #tuttletwins for the win

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Maribeth Cogan

“My just-turned-5 year old told me he is planning to read all the #TuttleTwins books today. It’s 10AM on Saturday and he’s already on his third. #Homeschooling ftw.”

★ ★ ★ ★ ★